Mind & Body

Think Most People Agree With You? You Might Be Fooling Yourself

Let's pretend you love pizza with anchovies. Your family also loves anchovy pizza — growing up, that's all you ever ordered. When your best friends would come over to hang out, they also opted for pizza with anchovies. Who needs any other topping? Now you're a manager at a company. You want to celebrate your team's recent accomplishments, so you order something they'll surely love: anchovy pizza. Everyone politely takes a piece but picks around the fish. What gives? This scenario is an example of the false-consensus effect. Because you and your loved ones share a preference in pizza, you falsely assumed that everyone did.

Everybody Thinks Like Me

The false-consensus effect is a cognitive bias that was coined by researcher Lee Ross and his colleagues in 1976. In one experiment, study participants had to decide which of two possible ways they'd respond to a specific conflict, such as whether they'd contest a ticket for which they may be guilty, or whether to vote for a space-research funding bill that would lead to higher taxes. They were also asked which option they believed other people would choose, and to describe the type of people who would make those choices.

In the end, regardless of which option the participants chose, they tended to think that most people would choose the same one. Interestingly, the participants also gave more extreme descriptions of the people who didn't choose their preferred option. They viewed their own choice as normal, thus assuming that the majority of people would make the same decision.

Related Video: 4 Mental Shortcuts That Can Cloud Your Judgment

Belief Bias

But why? The previous pizza scenario highlights one possible cause of the false-consensus effect called the availability heuristic. While estimating the likelihood that others share your beliefs, you'll probably consider the first people who come to mind: your family and friends. The fact that so many examples of people agreeing with you come to mind so quickly might lead you to believe that a higher proportion of the population loves briney pizza toppings than actually does. The false-consensus effect might also be a way to preserve self-esteem. We're motivated to think that other people share our thoughts and feelings — if they didn't, that might suggest there's something wrong with us.

When do people usually fall prey to the false-consensus effect? When they're absolutely sure. The more invested and confident we are about something, the more we assume others agree with us.

Get stories like this one in your inbox or your headphones: sign up for our daily email and subscribe to the Curiosity Daily podcast.

For more ways your brain plays tricks on you, check out "You Are Not So Smart: Why You Have Too Many Friends on Facebook, Why Your Memory Is Mostly Fiction, an d 46 Other Ways You're Deluding Yourself" by David McRaney. The audiobook is free with an Audible trial. We handpick reading recommendations we think you may like. If you choose to make a purchase, Curiosity will get a share of the sale.

Written by Anna Todd November 30, 2016

Curiosity uses cookies to improve site performance, for analytics and for advertising. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies, our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.